Plain rooms run by temple trusts, gurdwaras and charities, often near the shrine, at low cost or for a donation.
How to book
Check the trust's official site if it has one.
Otherwise go to the enquiry counter of the shrine or dharamshala.
Show your identity card and pay at the counter, or as a donation where that is the rule.
Keep in mind
Many do not take advance bookings outside the trust's own site.
Rooms are basic, and house rules on meals, alcohol and closing time apply.
Govt
Forest rest houses, dak bungalows and circuit houses
Rest houses of forest, public works and district offices. Officials come first, and travellers get a room only when one is free.
How to book
Ask the forest office, public works office or Collectorate that runs it.
Apply with your identity card and your dates.
Pay at the rest house or as the office tells you.
Keep in mind
There is usually no online booking; call before you go.
An official on duty can take the room even after you book.
Green: government. Blue: trust or NGO. Yellow: private. Read from the map's operator details and the place's name, so a place we could not recognise is shown as private.
See today's prices for private hotels on Google Hotels.
Cocon-huts Resort: ₹150-₹250. Come out of the jetty and walk straight up to main road, turn right and walk about 500m down road, then turn right straight after the football pitch, nice friendly staff, 10 basic cheap huts with decent communal shower and bathroom facilities set in nice large open area, opens out onto beach, 4 bungalows are available but apparently have to be booked from Port Blair
Hawabill nest guest house (IP&T): ₹150. Near the jetty proved to be a very decent place. The Dorms are clean with proper beds and a community bath/toilet. Good news, there were no other tourists except an occasional day tripper family. They also have a chef who can prepare the food on request. To book contact A&N Tourism
Pearl Park Beach Resort: 2.5 km west of the ferry dock. Another 500 metres further west from Tango and pretty much the same except it doesn't front onto the beach. Similar pricing to Tango
Source: Wikivoyage, Neil Island, written by volunteers (CC BY-SA 4.0), not a government source. Prices and timings may be old; confirm before you travel.