Buses to Alibag
Government buses, including AC buses
What travellers say
MSRTC buses should be available from various parts of Maharashtra. If you are leaving from Mumbai, then you have an option of boarding MSRTC buses, leaving every 30 mins - 1 hr from the Mumbai Central Bus Station. Though they might be uncomfortable, they top in terms of punctuality. Remember to grab a window seat! Private buses can be chartered, a good option if you are going in a large group.
Source: Wikivoyage, Alibag, written by volunteers (CC BY-SA 4.0), not a government source. Prices and timings may be old; confirm before you travel.